We now offer Door Dash of many of our popular in stock items. Get our treats delivered right to your door!

Sun – Mon | CLOSED     Tues – Fri | 9am – 5pm     Saturday | 9am – 12pm

Welcome to the sweetest shop in Dover

Amy's Custom Cakery specializes in wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and more.

Affordable wedding cakes in York
custom wedding cakes for your wedding
party and birthday cakes in York, PA
the best cake bakery in York, PA

Amy’s Custom Cakery creates delicious, memorable buttercream and fondant cakes, cupcakes, cake pops, and much more. 

Stop by the bakery and treat yourself, or a loved one!

specialty cake design in York, PA
gourmet cupcakes and candies in York, PA
Custom cake and cake decoration
custom themed cakes for parties


83 W. Canal Street
Dover, PA 17315

We have cakes and sweet treats available at all times! 

Please allow two weeks notice for all custom orders.


Sunday – Closed 
Monday- Closed
Tuesday –  9 AM – 5 PM
Wednesday – 9 AM – 5 PM
Thursday – 9 AM – 5 PM
Friday – 9 AM – 5 PM
Saturday – 9 AM – 12 PM


During special holidays, we run online ordering through the website. As always, the option to stop by our shop or call us to place an order is available. Please note that we require a two-week notice for all custom orders.