Amy’s first opened its doors on December 5, 2011.

Amy first found a love for baking and cake decorating when she was 16 years old and began working as a cake decorator at a local grocery store. While a student in college, Amy began dreaming of having her own bakery after working as a wedding cake decorator.

Her passion led her to attend Pennsylvania’s College of Technology, where she received her associates degree in baking and pastry arts. After graduating, Amy’s Custom Cakery became a reality in Dover, PA, when she was only 19 years old.

Amy’s Custom Cakery has remained a steady, consistent staple of the community over the last decade, serving up wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and other sweet treats for all types of weddings, events, and celebrations. As the shop grew, Amy brought on more skilled professionals, and together, the team creates a wide range of styles to accommodate all of their client’s needs. From trend-worthy wedding cakes to impressive recreations of everyday items, custom orders, or a quick stop-in for a last-minute pre-made cake from the cooler, Amy’s has it all.

Four years ago, a new neighbor moved in beside Amy’s shop, Taqueria El Camino, creating a small culinary hub between them. You can’t miss the colorful building and inviting atmosphere located directly across from Dover Area Middle School! Visitors can enjoy a unique fusion of flavors at El Camino from Chef Ethan Greer and follow up with delicious desserts directly from Amy’s cases.